Gooey on the Inside Cookie Butter Review

Gooey on the Inside Cookie Butter Review
Gifted By: Gooey on the Inside
gooeyontheinside.com
Reviewed by Arielle Matlin, Editor, TheBestDessertRecipes.com


Gooey on the Inside is taking cookie butter to a whole new level with innovative and divine flavors. Cookie butter is a relatively new concept, but one that has caught on quite quickly. We sampled all sorts of unique cookie butter flavors including: Smores, Chocolate Chip Chunk, Birthday Cake, FlufferNana, Red Velvet White Chocolate Cream-Cheese Frosting, and Marshmallow Crispy Treat. Some of the favorites were the Chocolate Chip Chunk and Birthday Cake.

We found most of the flavors to be just the right amount of sweet. They are super light and fluffy. You can eat the cookie butter with pretzels, graham crackers, bread, or just a spoon! They are also great for using in baked goods. A coworker made oatmeal cookie butter bars and they were gone in seconds. A few people found the butters to be too close to tasting like frosting, but for some of us, we found that to be a good thing!

The Chocolate Chip Chunk cookie butter pairs perfectly with pretzels for the sweet and savory bite. The Birthday Cake cookie butter incorporates sprinkles, which really helps create the birthday cake effect. Some people compared it to the Cake Batter Ice Cream found at Coldstone Creamery. We found the FlufferNana flavor, a combination of marshmallow fluff and bananas, a bit too banana flavored. The Smores flavor was also a crowd-favorite. We think it would be out-of-this-world incorporated into a homemade brownie recipe.

These cookie butters from Gooey on the Inside are incredibly delicious. For anyone with a sweet tooth, they make for a great little sugar fix. The fun flavors and delightful tastes have us excited about what they will come up with next!