PB&J Thumbprint Cookies

"Okay, okay you caught me. They're not actually thumbprint cookies. I have a weird thing about sticking my thumb into cookie dough. I just can't. It makes ZERO sense because I'm totally rolling the cookie dough into balls with my hands, but that last step of poking it with my thumb? Not going to happen. Go ahead, judge my weirdness. I totally am. If you want to use your thumb for these, by all means do, but I used the back of a wooden spoon and it worked just fine. No thumbing necessary. (I feel weird even typing that)."

Why You'll Love This Cookie Recipe

1. Easy to make: These PB&J Thumbprint Cookies are simple to whip up, requiring just a few basic ingredients and minimal steps. Perfect for a quick and delicious treat!

2. Fun twist on a classic: Give the traditional thumbprint cookie a unique twist with the classic combination of peanut butter and jelly flavors. A nostalgic and satisfying treat for kids and adults alike.

3. No thumb required: Don't feel like getting your hands dirty by sticking your thumb into the cookie dough? No problem! Use the back of a wooden spoon instead for the same effect without the thumbing.

4. Versatile filling options: While this recipe calls for classic jelly as the filling, feel free to get creative and use other types of jam or even chocolate spread for a customizable twist on the traditional PB&J flavor combo.

5. Perfect for sharing: Whether it's a school lunchbox treat, a party dessert, or a sweet gift for a friend, these PB&J Thumbprint Cookies are sure to be a crowd-pleaser. Make a big batch and spread the love with these delicious cookies.