Best Ever Buckeyes

By: TheBestDessertRecipes.com Test Kitchen

Best Ever Buckeyes

By: TheBestDessertRecipes.com Test Kitchen

Buckeye candies are a classic potluck treat! This homemade candy recipe needs less than five ingredients but makes enough buckeyes for an entire party full of people! This dessert combines chocolate and peanut butter in the most satisfying way. These treats are sure to have guests reaching for seconds and thirds because they are just that irresistible.
If you leave in the toothpicks that you use to dip your candy in chocolate, it makes them even easier to serve. If you've never tried this peanut butter and chocolate recipe, try making it for your next gathering. Use your favorite brand of peanut butter when you make the recipe so it taste exactly the way you like it.

Notes

Candy melts are especially formulated to give a smooth, glossy chocolate finish that will not melt too easily on the fingers when served. You can substitute chocolate chips if necessary.

For another great homemade candy recipe, try Crunchy Homemade Peanut Brittle.

Makes60 buckeyes

Ingredients

2 cups smooth creamy peanut butter
2 sticks butter, softened to room temperature
1 1/2 pound powdered sugar
12 ounces chocolate melts (see note)

Instructions

In an electric mixer, combine peanut butter with butter until completely smooth. Beat in powdered sugar gradually until well combined. It should have the consistency of wet sand. Pinch some between your fingers to be sure it holds together add a tablespoon of water and mix further if necessary.
Form dough into 1-inch balls between your palms and place on a parchment lined bake sheet. Chill for 1 hour.
Place chocolate melts into a glass or metal bowl and set over a pan of simmering water until it can be stirred with a spoon into a smooth mixture. Use a toothpick or skewer to spear each ball and dip into the chocolate, leaving about of the top uncovered, and allowing excess to drip off before placing on another parchment lined bake sheet. Use a fingertip to smooth over the hole made by the toothpick.
Cover completed candies with plastic wrap and chill or freeze until serving time.

Your Recently Viewed Recipes

Rate

I have not made this yet so I cannot rate it.

We are adding your Comments.

Thank you! Your comment has been added.

We are sorry. There was an error tyring to post your rating and review.

Your comment will appear after our editors have had a chance to review it.

Cancel Reply to Comment

Thanks for your comment. Don't forget to share!

SissieSass

Jul 29, 2018

I can never get the texture of the peanut butter layer to turn out right. It is always runny or crumbly. Do you have any tips that can help me out? My mom said that my butter was probably too soft, but I don't know how to tell when it is ready to use for this recipe.

Blando Calrissian

Jul 26, 2018

Buckeyes are the perfect chocolate and peanut butter treat! These were delicious!

daniellek

Jan 08, 2016

Peanut butter and chocolate really is the perfect combination. I can't wait to make this easy recipe at home!

shelfconsciouskati e

Oct 26, 2015

I was worried that these would be too sweet for me, but they really hit the spot!

Dana N

Oct 26, 2015

Yummmm peanut butter and chocolate, can't go wrong!

Kristina K

Oct 23, 2015

Maybe I'm just sick of the peanut butter & chocolate combination, but it didn't really do it for me. If that's what you want, though, this is perfect for you.

EditorLP

Oct 23, 2015

Chocolate PB = amazing. More chocolate would add a better balance between the two delicious flavors.

amatlin

Oct 23, 2015

So yummy! I thought they would be too rich, but they were perfect!

AFC Editor Annalis a

Oct 22, 2015

Chocolate and peanut butter is my favorite dessert combination, and these were another example of why! So good!

kblindt 8571579

Oct 22, 2015

You can't go wrong with chocolate and peanut butter in my opinion and these buckeyes were no exception. So good... I may have to have another!

emenems

Oct 22, 2015

These were delicious!! The peanut butter mixture was absolutely perfect and creamy!

caitlinmm

Oct 22, 2015

These are a great party recipe. They are so good! I like a thicker chocolate coating on buckeyes to balance the peanut butter flavor

dmodrowski

Oct 22, 2015

These were the first buckeyes I've ever tried, but I liked them a lot! Chocolate and peanut butter - how could you go wrong?

SaraR

Oct 22, 2015

I wanted to shove fifty of these things in my mouth all at once. Just give me all of them. Right now.

Lizz C

Oct 22, 2015

This recipe for buckeyes is pretty good. I've had A LOT of treats like this before, and these are OK. All together, it's creamy and tastes like peanut butter, so it's doing its job. I could definitely eat a whole tray of these.